
A common question that comes up by students in author presentations is: Where does one get ideas for stories? Or to put it another way: How does one get a story started? But what never gets asked about is the bookend question, after a story has been introduced and been well explored and now it’s time to wrap things up? How straightforward is it to end a story?
For example, how many times have you been caught off guard by a movie’s abrupt ending where you’ve gone: Oh, is that it then? Books are different because we are somewhat prepared for the ending simply by the thinning out of unread pages, and yet even then, haven’t you ever wondered how a huge story you’ve been so invested in was going to satisfyingly conclude with the few pages you have left to read? Inversely, have you ever watched a movie in which you believed the natural spot to end had arrived, only to find the director didn’t agree and continued on for many more minutes?
Kurt Vonnegut believed that a story should conclude shortly after its central conflict has been resolved. Lingering too long afterwards, risks diluting its power. This is a rule adopted in sketch comedy too. Once you’ve fully explored the premise, get off the stage as soon as possible. You can see this philosophy applied often on Saturday Night Live where most sketch’s end quickly without any finesse or attempt at a clean conclusion.
Some authors would say that the story ends when the big question posed at the beginning has been answered. Others would say that it is when the protagonist has sufficiently changed. The third way, which I like, and which I’ve read has been attributed to Anton Chekhov is to simply ask: has the story said what it came to say?
I want to highlight two non-literary sources. One is a podcast and the other is the reality TV show about visual art.
Let’s begin with the latter. Portrait Artist of the Year follows a yearly competition in the UK. The artists that take part have been shortlisted from thousands of entries, each having submitted a self-portrait. But now, in the next stage, they must paint or draw a live model introduced to them in an already determined pose along with background. They can approach the assignment in any way they wish, but they have only four hours to complete the piece of art.
It’s fascinating to watch numerous artists tackle the same subject matter. A writer can draw easy parallels (this last sentence only works as a metaphor as I have no idea if a writer can even draw a square, but moving on …). Does the artist apply a classical approach or go for something minimalistic in style, for example? Does the artist choose to broadly capture the subject, background included, or do they focus in on just the face and what story can be revealed within just the expression? Some artists attack the work right away, some spend an hour or more strategically placing small marks of paints on canvas, mapping out the balances of colour, or which elements will deliberately stand out. But to the point of this blog post, one issue that came up was when artists captured the essence of their subject long before the allotted time was up but didn’t feel confident enough to stop there. What ended up happening was that they overworked their piece, and whatever was initially discovered or revealed, in its uniqueness or vitality, got pulled under layers of more paint and subsequently lost what made it special.
Inversely, a story could end too soon. Heavyweight is a podcast I really enjoy. It is created by Jonathan Goldstein. Canadian radio listeners might remember him from an earlier show, Wiretap, which implemented recorded phone conversations that left the listener wondering if they were scripted or truly voyeuristic intrusions into other people’s lives. Goldstein, as a side note, is also an author of several books. Lenny Bruce is Dead and Ladies and Gentlemen, the Bible are two that I liked. With Heavyweight, he really brings his narrative skills to good use and he does so uniquely by using the lives of real people as his sculpting material.
The premise of each episode is built on an individual’s need for closure for something that has remained unresolved and uneasy in their life. They could be seeking an explanation or an apology or forgiveness, and Jonathan, in his self-deprecating, nebbish personae, will help guide this person towards their goal. It is funny, because Jonathan is naturally funny, in a lowkey way, but it is also at times quite poignant, scratching at human truths that resonate beyond just that specific person’s need. Some episodes have left me teary. These stories, I understand, can take many months and in a few cases, even years to complete. Some never make it to airing, because the research and investigating did not bear fruit, so there was no worthy story to tell despite the potential.
One recent episode comes to mind because it again addresses the question of when a story is finished. In this case, the man who serves as protagonist of this story wanted closure for a lie he told around thirty years earlier which he believed had major consequences. He wanted to confess the lie and he wanted, if possible, forgiveness. As it turned out, the magnitude of fallout for telling this lie was not nearly as big as the man had imagined all this time, and the forgiveness was readily given by those he thought he’d hurt. For the man, this was unsatisfying, and for the story, it was a meh ending. But Goldstein, who wasn’t just the narrator but the “writer”, was not willing to call this story finished. So he digged deeper. He reviewed the hours of recorded phone conversations looking for hints of what was missed, what clues overlooked. He finds a different angle to the story and poses the question to the man that maybe the forgiveness he’s seeking is from a different party. This resonates with the man, and story-wise, it’s satisfying for the listener too. The revelation of an emotional blockage that kept the real dramatic situation hidden is story gold. The follow-up scene with the true source of the man’s shame brings real closure, and a much more satisfying finish (in a surprising way) but it wouldn’t have happened if Jonathan Goldstein let the original ending stand.
I’ll end this post here, for now. I suspect a better ending might come along in the comments if someone wishes to share their opinion or guiding rule to finishing a story.
On a side note, if you accidently do a search on this subject using the prompt: When is a story Finnish? You will be told it will include recurring elements of deep forests, lakes and islands, long winters, snow, darkness, silence and other Nordic tropes.
Leave a Reply