
To be an author is the A.I. era is to endure an endless barrage of scam emails intent on parting you from your money. And I mean it is relentless, almost daily and sometimes several in a day. It wastes your time because each one requires at least some focus before you discern it is trash to be rid of.
Like the Nigerian prince scam from those more innocent days of the internet, these emails also follow a consistent pattern. It begins with the writer saying how they “stumbled” upon one of my books, as if a copy had been lying on the sidewalk. I’ve had every single one of my books be the focus of at least one of these scams, which is ridiculous because some of them are out of print. Then the writer tells me they were blown away by the story, touched by (insert detail here), yada, yada, yada. And then comes the ask, which can go in one of two ways. The writer might ask if there is a publisher already committed to this book (a strange ask, considering they wouldn’t even know about the book if it hadn’t been published, but I suppose the assumption is that the book has been just self-published). But if not that, then the scam writer asks if I would like my book promoted beyond its current limited scope by means of their magic marketing, but never do they offer any examples of their work or a link to a website that might support their claims.
The worst or laziest versions don’t even bother to mention the name of the book they liked. They simply came across “a book of mine” that they loved/were touched by/etc. The surnames of these interested parties are weirdly sometimes also first names. I’ve had emails from Lisa Deborah, Allie Colleen or James Brian. I’ve also had an email from Peculiar Tumilara (name generator on the fritz?) and another from Evelyn Book (which is a bit on the nose, don’t you think?)
The fact that all these scam emails sound alike should not surprise us. We see that kind of repetition in A.I. in all sorts of things. A.I. is likely learning from examples it already had created. But two things really bother me about these emails. First, the scammers are preying on writers. I mean, come on. This isn’t exactly a wealthy demographic to be fleecing. However, it is worth noting that nearly two million books are published in America every 1-2 years. That is the equivalent of all the titles published in the 20th century (read: The Untold Story of Books: A Writer’s History of Book Publishing). If the vast majority are self-published, then for these scammers, it’s more of a trawling expedition than a fishing trip. Send out enough emails, and maybe you catch a few desperate souls understandably wanting a bigger audience reach.
The other element to this that I find to be even worse is that these letters of praise are not short. No, they are eloquent, verbose paeans to your book, a synthesized version of every positive review and comment that A.I. has scoured off the internet. It is all the praise you’ve ever dreamed of receiving for your book. You feel totally seen and understood. And yet you know that it is fake so it feels like a cruel prank, played over and over, every single day.
Do these scams make money? I really have no idea. Did the Nigerian prince scams catch a fish or two? For a much longer time, I’ve been getting publishing scams over the phone with actual real people trying to lure me in. It’s quite sad, to be honest. They are obviously reading a script and often reading it badly. They leave long messages on my answering machine in the hopes I’ll actually call them back. It’s always my book Alphabetter, which they want to publish, which if anyone did any real research they would know that it had its success years ago but now is out of print. At the beginning, when this first started, I would tell them as much and ask to be removed from their list. They would say yes. But a month later, someone new would call, also about publishing Alphabetter, which means that this scam is being sold to other scammers, along with contact info, over and over and over. The callers will have different accents, which suggest it is being sold around the world, and I’m guessing the callers may be in financial difficulties themselves, trying to earn a commission on a very, very long shot based on bad, even useless information (I hope they at least get an hourly wage). I’m reminded that in the wonderful book, Every Day Is for the Thief by Teju Cole, the Nigerian prince scam is being conducted by poor Nigerian men, run out of internet cafes, late at night, paying for computer use by the hour, knowing it’s illegal if they get caught, pecking out the script, letter by letter, on a keyboard, hoping against hope that they get lucky.
Let me end this post on a lighter note, or at least a more bizarre one. The image at the top of the post is a screen shot of a scam email I received recently. A newer trend is for AI scams to use identity theft and claim to be the real person and/or a real company in the publishing industry. Arguably, that’s an evolutionary step away from the early stuff written by “Sally Cindy”. However, in this case, they are using the CEO of Simon & Schuster. And guess what? He just stumbled upon one of my Very, Very Far North series books. I would bloody well hope he did! Afterall, his company did already publish it.
Leave a Reply